Guide · 6 Min Read
Mail Memories vs Google Takeout vs Browser Extensions for Gmail Photos
By Carlos Foster, creator of Mail Memories · Updated
Summary
Google Takeout is free and backs up every email you have, but it gives you a huge file that’s hard to get photos out of. Browser extensions are quick for a batch of recent attachments, but most need access to your whole mailbox. Mail Memories saves every photo in your account to folders sorted by year, without your email passing through anyone’s server, but it only handles photos and costs $29 after the free 100.
I make Mail Memories, so I’m obviously not neutral here. I’ve tried to be fair anyway, including about what my app doesn’t do. All three options are good at something. The right one depends on what you’re trying to end up with.
The quick comparison.
| Google Takeout | Browser extensions | Mail Memories | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free | Free versions with limits, or a subscription | Oldest 100 photos free, then $29 once |
| What you get | Every email, as one .mbox file |
Attachments from the emails you pick | Every photo attachment in your account |
| Organized by date | No | Depends on the extension | Yes, year and month folders |
| Who handles your email | Google only | Often the extension’s developer too | Google and your computer only |
| Videos and documents | Yes, inside the emails | Usually | No, photos only |
| Best for | A full backup of all your email | A few recent attachments | Getting every photo out, sorted |
Google Takeout: free and complete, but not built for photos.
Google Takeout is Google’s own export tool. You choose Gmail, Google builds an archive of your whole mailbox, and emails you a link to download it.
What it does well:
- It’s free and it comes straight from Google, so no one else touches your data.
- It’s complete. Every email, every attachment, every label. If you want a true backup of your account, nothing else comes close.
Where it falls short for photos:
- There’s no photo-only option. You get everything, which for a long-time Gmail user can be tens of gigabytes.
- It can take hours or days for Google to build the archive.
- Your photos end up inside an
.mboxfile. You can’t double-click it and see pictures. Getting the photos out means importing it into an email program or running extra software.
I go into more detail in my guide on downloading Gmail photos without Google Takeout.
Browser extensions: handy for a batch, but check what you’re agreeing to.
Search the Chrome Web Store for “Gmail attachment downloader” and you’ll find a lot. Most add a button to Gmail that saves attachments from the emails you select, often as a zip file or straight to Google Drive.
What they do well:
- They work right inside Gmail, so there’s nothing else to install.
- They’re quick for a specific batch, like every attachment from one sender last month.
- Many save every attachment type, not just photos.
What to watch out for:
- To work, most need permission to read your entire mailbox, and some keep that access until you remove it.
- Some download your email through their own servers rather than your browser. The privacy policy usually says which.
- Free versions are often capped at a small number of emails, and the full versions tend to be monthly subscriptions.
- Many of them haven’t been updated in years. Check the “Updated” date on the store page before you install one.
None of that means every extension is a bad choice. Just know who you’re giving access to, and remove the access from your Google Account connections when you’re done.
Mail Memories: every photo, sorted, and nothing in between.
Mail Memories is a desktop app for Mac and Windows that does one thing: find every photo attachment in your Gmail and save it to your computer.
What it does well:
- It searches your whole account, back to the first email, including archived and sent mail.
- Photos land in folders like “2006” → “07 - July”, with the date and subject of the email in each file name. The same photo forwarded five times is saved once.
- It runs on your computer and connects straight to Gmail with a Google App Password you can revoke anytime. Your email and photos never go through my servers or anyone else’s.
- It’s a one-time payment, not a subscription. The free scan saves your 100 oldest photos first, so you can see what’s there before paying.
What it doesn’t do:
- It only saves photos. No videos, PDFs, or other documents.
- It only works with Gmail, and only on a Mac or Windows computer, not a phone.
- It doesn’t open zip files attached to emails.
- You need 2-Step Verification on your Google account to create the App Password it uses. If that’s giving you trouble, see my guide on fixing an App Password that’s missing or not working.
See what it finds before you decide
Your 100 oldest Gmail photos are free to download, in a few minutes.
No credit card required · Runs 100% locally
So which one should you use?
- You want a backup of all your email. Use Google Takeout. It’s free, and it’s worth doing once anyway.
- You need a handful of attachments from recent emails. Gmail’s own download buttons are fine, or an extension you trust.
- You want every photo from the last ten or twenty years, sorted and on your computer. That’s what Mail Memories is for.
- You want both. Run Takeout for the full backup and Mail Memories for the photos. They don’t interfere with each other.
If the photos are for the whole family, my guide on backing up photos from a parent’s or relative’s Gmail covers saving more than one account.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a free alternative to Google Takeout for Gmail photos?
For a few photos, Gmail’s own search and download buttons are free. Mail Memories downloads your 100 oldest Gmail photos for free too. Saving every photo in a large account with Mail Memories is a one-time $29 payment.
Can I use Google Takeout and Mail Memories together?
Yes, and it’s a good idea. Takeout gives you a full backup of every email, while Mail Memories gives you the photos in folders you can actually browse. They don’t interfere with each other.
Are Chrome extensions for downloading Gmail attachments safe?
Some are, but most ask for permission to read your entire mailbox, and some process your email on their own servers. Before installing one, check who makes it, when it was last updated, and what its privacy policy says it does with your email.
Does Mail Memories download videos and PDFs?
No. Mail Memories only saves photos: JPG, PNG, GIF, WebP, HEIC, and TIFF files. For videos, documents, or a copy of every email, Google Takeout is the better tool.